"In music there are certain moments which somehow evade rational calculations or planning. After all this is the secret of art: it somehow escapes from a complete intellectual control. Of course, it affects the mind and is created by it, but this is a different matter. [...] In 20th century music the aesthetics of beauty ceased to function and while the category of beauty could be applied to certain particular sounds, in general the aesthetics of beauty belongs in the past. It is in the Renaissance or the Baroque periods that the primary task of an artist was to create beauty or truth. Now, the purpose of art is not to provide beauty nor truth, but rather evoke certain emotions which are intellectual more often than artistic."
Krzysztof Baculewski in an unpublished interview by Trochimczyk, 1986
I was playing the Mozart flute and harp concerto today: not one of Mozart's deepest or darkest works, but because so much of the harp repertoire is crap by neglected composers, Mozart's concerto buckles, among harpists, under disproportionate intellectual tonnage. Which ornaments to use? What cadenza?
I'm not going to the library for this concerto. It's infinitely more than pretty (I think flowery renditions of it are cheap), but its beauty is here, right now. There is wonderful drama but, whichever feeling the music portrays at any one moment is directly here, distilled, uncomplicated. That's why Romantic interpretations don't work, because Romantic feeling is at best always slightly tortured. The Andantino, soaring forth: is it so difficult just to play it? To let it go? To let go?
One general paradox of adult human existence is that we have to learn how to be simple. The Alexander Technique trains us back to the natural postures of children; the greatest artists are clear. It is difficult to let the Andantino go, because we superimpose our habits; false rallentandos, Romantic exaggeration, or sapping the music of its drama and energy by failing to sustain a crescendo or a forte.
But I think we study simplicity not just because of whatever personal detritus we've collected along life's way, but because there is nonetheless a knowingness to be gleaned beyond gut feeling, or a baby's chaotic instinct. The perfect balance of Mozart's music, there for the taking if you take infinite pains. Use whichever ornaments you like. Just let them be right.
The word enlightenment: bringing light. Growing lighter. Learning. Soaring.